Strong dissents from Thomas, Alito Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito wrote dissents.
|
|
In dissents, Justice Scalia didn't need to garner a consensus.
|
|
There was no further explanation provided and no dissents filed.
|
|
The document did not note any public votes or dissents.
|
|
Judge Garland's voice is most vivid in his infrequent dissents.
|
|
There were no dissents in the Fed's decision on Wednesday.
|
|
Pompeo challenged the president or dissents from his existing convictions.
|
|
It was an order of two sentences with no noted dissents.
|
|
The news was announced in an order with no noted dissents.
|
|
Now it is her scorching dissents that draw most public attention.
|
|
The court's opinion was unanimous, and there were no noted dissents.
|
|
Far fewer Republicans agreed that such dissents were compatible with patriotism.
|
|
Despite their dissents, the senate voted 78-22 to confirm Roberts.
|
|
Relf studies the alethiometer and dissents, quietly, from the Church's authority.
|
|
Sotomayor, joined by Kagan, dissents, essentially saying: Are you kidding me?
|
|
The three judges who noted dissents were appointed by Republican presidents.
|
|
His dissents were rarely witty, his jokes too many and not funny.
|
|
First of all, you had two dissents, but they said, 'No cut.
|
|
She was prolific, writing more than 19813 opinions, including several notable dissents.
|
|
There were no noted dissents in the high court's two-sentence order.
|
|
She continues to speak boldly through her dissents, but also during interviews.
|
|
But even those dissents from inside the party were not too widespread.
|
|
The court's order was brief, gave no reasons and noted no dissents.
|
|
That was the most dissents for a Fed decision since December 2014.
|
|
A. In his dissents, Justice Scalia often wrote like he was just talking.
|
|
Justice John Paul Stevens gave one of the dissents to the Court's decision.
|
|
The Washington Post reports that there were no recorded dissents to the decision.
|
|
The nation's first Italian-American justice, Scalia didn't sugarcoat his often blunt dissents.
|
|
In each case, Kennedy's stance drew strenuous dissents from the court's other conservatives.
|
|
But that's in part because she doesn't use that tone in most dissents.
|
|
Brandeis's opinion in Olmstead is one of those dissents which outlive the decision.
|
|
There were no notable dissents from the court's refusal to hear Young's case.
|
|
Ironically, it does so by deploying principles established in Holmes's free speech dissents.
|
|
The court's brief order gave no reasons, and there were no noted dissents.
|
|
The divisions were reflected in dissents that came from both hawks and doves.
|
|
As a result, he often wrote solo dissents, but his opinions are nonetheless memorable.
|
|
Scalia's dissents almost always produced a quote that was instantly recognizable as his voice.
|
|
Scalia's fiery and blunt dissents have become legendary and are signature of his legacy.
|
|
Only Justice Clarence Thomas wrote more dissents last term, but his agenda was different.
|
|
Two other Kavanaugh Fourth Amendment dissents should also raise alarms about his privacy views.
|
|
The order was not not signed nor was it accompanied by any noted dissents.
|
|
Beyond that, he's written very hot dissents in the contraception mandate case over Obamacare.
|
|
The decision to keep rates unchanged was unanimous, following several dissents in recent meetings.
|
|
" MICHAEL ARONE, CHIEF INVESTMENT STRATEGIST, STATE STREET GLOBAL ADVISORS, BOSTON "The two biggest takeaways in the early going are the number of dissents and the fact the dissents are opposing each other suggesting the Fed can't reach a consensus on its own.
|
|
You write that Mr. Scalia's style was most distinctive in his dissents, which were numerous.
|
|
He wrote some of the dissents in Korematsu and some of the most significant cases.
|
|
Indeed, those dissents often ended up carrying the day, as with 1988's Morrison v.
|
|
MOST front-page Supreme Court stories involve fraught cases, closely divided votes and biting dissents.
|
|
Kagan has written righteously angry dissents before, but she does not do so a lot.
|
|
Twelve of them were dissents because she wanted a rate hike when others did not.
|
|
Three judges all appointed by Republican presidents filed three separate dissents, each joining the other.
|
|
"The dissents have a policy disagreement, not just with Ohio, but with Congress," Alito wrote.
|
|
The latest application was denied by the full Supreme Court without comment or noted dissents.
|
|
"The dissents have a policy disagreement, not just with Ohio, but with Congress," he wrote.
|
|
And even Ms. Brainard, who dissents regularly on such matters, sounded comfortable with the decision.
|
|
Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Neil Gorsuch, in separate dissents, took issue with the majority's formula.
|
|
If you get a good deal of dissents, the markets are going to discount future moves.
|
|
He has lamented in several dissents his colleagues' refusal to take up challenges to gun laws.
|
|
That said, Garland does not write scorched-earth dissents highlighting flaws he uncovers in colleagues' opinions.
|
|
The dissent While the majority opinion covered 23 pages, the dissents covered a total of 92.
|
|
Two biting dissents from Justices Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor took sharp issue with this holding.
|
|
The opinions were all dissents from the court's decisions not to hear particular gun-rights appeals.
|
|
There were no noted dissents from Wednesday's opinion, which appeared to be the product of compromise.
|
|
However, three justices wrote dissents to say the bar on "scandalous" trademarks should have been upheld.
|
|
For now, the Louisiana law is on hold and bitter abortion related dissents are at bay.
|
|
"In light of the dissents, we will be seeking review at the Supreme Court," he said.
|
|
Dissents are extremely rare, with Wilson's being only the second one in the previous 15 years.
|
|
Only two members of the Court, Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor, registered public dissents.
|
|
If just one juror dissents, Roof will receive life in prison without the possibility of parole.
|
|
In dissents especially, his style really catered to an audience as much outside the profession as within.
|
|
In multiple dissents, they argued that the majority deeply misunderstood the Supreme Court's precedents and their goals.
|
|
His laser-sharp dissents garnered a lot of attention, but he didn't just talk through his opinions.
|
|
Morgan Stanley economists expect a half percentage point cut, and they note that dissents are not uncommon.
|
|
"They threw in one statement on … global developments … and we got two dissents as expected," said Boockvar.
|
|
After scores of similar dissents, no wonder that the public has a low opinion of the court.
|
|
His two Republican colleagues spoke in favor of the repeal, while the two Democrats offered harsh dissents.
|
|
Since 1936 nearly three-quarters of hawkish dissents on the FOMC have come from regional Fed presidents.
|
|
The justices reportedly feared that any dissents or compromises would cause the president to defy the court.
|
|
Three members of the Commission on Care refused to sign the report in protest and wrote dissents.
|
|
Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor noted dissents from Thursday's order, which was brief and unsigned.
|
|
Their dissents recognized that the death penalty is inherently arbitrary and commonly racist and hence never permissible.
|
|
At times, people nodded to Mr. Sanford's dissents, urging him to venture further out on a limb.
|
|
"We probably do a better job criticizing ourselves in our dissents than anybody else could," he said.
|
|
The former could be dismissed as the normal dissents of a relative few within a broader team.
|
|
Not all judges approve of such dissents, particularly when they are aimed at eliciting Supreme Court review.
|
|
The Supreme Court order, which only covers the Ohio case, included no noted dissents from the eight justices.
|
|
"If I am their lawyers, I am not optimistic, given that there were no recorded dissents," Vladeck said.
|
|
The Fed's decision to lower borrowing costs last month drew three dissents, the most of Mr. Powell's tenure.
|
|
She spoke about his career, his big dissents and the opinions he wrote that no other justice joined.
|
|
If one of the 12 jurors dissents, the defendant must be sentenced to life without parole, Hornsby said.
|
|
The court's most conservative members — Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr. — wrote eight concurrences or dissents.
|
|
He said it took massive, well-organized, nonviolent dissents for black Americans to earn the right to vote.
|
|
The vote was 7 to 2, with Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Neil M. Gorsuch each filing dissents.
|
|
Mainstream reviews, mainly written by white, non-Latino critics, were largely admiring, though there were some strong dissents.
|
|
The U.S. central bank's decision to keep borrowing costs unchanged was unanimous, following several dissents in recent meetings.
|
|
As is typical, the justices did not explain their reasoning, and there were no dissents from the denial.
|
|
This is the simple-math way of thinking: In a democracy, the majority decides, and the minority dissents.
|
|
But it is a setback for the company, particularly given the absence of any noted dissents in the order.
|
|
Commissioner Mignon Clyburn says she dissents as she is "among the millions" who are "outraged" by the FCC's conduct.
|
|
The leading pioneer of the legal doctrine of Originalism, Scalia leaves behind a legacy of contentious decisions and dissents.
|
|
Dissents are rare on the NRC and the two members who hold Democratic seats strongly disagreed with the approval.
|
|
But a series of recent dissents from Thomas and his most conservative colleagues shows how he may yet win.
|
|
" MARK GRANT, MANAGING DIRECTOR AND FIXED-INCOME STRATEGIST, HILLTOP SECURITIES, FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA: "The two dissents were worth notice.
|
|
Justice Ginsburg, 84, also described her grueling exercise routine, her link to a rap icon and her "graveyard" dissents.
|
|
All but two committee members voted for the cut, with the dissents believing that no further accommodation was needed.
|
|
The court issued a one sentence order on the ban -- which went into effect Tuesday -- with no noted dissents.
|
|
Chief Justice Roberts, for the four conservative justices, wrote one of his strongest dissents while on the Supreme Court.
|
|
In a spate of decisions and dissents, Gorsuch aligned with Clarence Thomas, the most conservative justice on the bench.
|
|
Justice Scalia began his service on the court as an outsider known for caustic dissents that alienated even potential allies.
|
|
Thomas dissents The case had prompted Justice Clarence Thomas, who rarely speaks during oral arguments, to ask a rare question.
|
|
In fact, Pai's dissents from the FCC bench are a must-see for any student of politics, law and regulation.
|
|
The committee saw division in 003, including three dissents in September as hawkish and dovish members argued for different policies.
|
|
The Supreme Court's brief order gave no reasons for staying out of the case and did not note any dissents.
|
|
Yet despite the research and the dissents from many Native people, these customs -- the racist names, the fan behaviors -- persist.
|
|
Justices often use dissents and concurrences to send signals about their interest in issues that aren't directly before the court.
|
|
The second reason to highlight Flake's dissents, when they happen, is that they're a reminder that Republicans are not unstoppable.
|
|
Kavanaugh dissents While Kavanaugh cast his vote with the conservatives on the court, he wrote separately to explain his thinking.
|
|
The Supreme Court rejected the appeal in a brief order with no noted dissents from any of the nine justices.
|
|
They also foreshadowed the future in some of their concurrences and dissents and votes to grant cases for the next term.
|
|
And anyone who dissents -- including media organizations that are his favorite targets -- can be branded disrespectful of the troops and unpatriotic.
|
|
The MP has been rallying opposition and dissents to his side and has even led a protest against some government policies.
|
|
Swonk said another consideration for the Fed to stay on hold is that it would risk fewer dissents at the meeting.
|
|
The commissioners laid out their concerns in written dissents, noting they would have preferred to held Zuckerberg liable in the complaint.
|
|
The dissents further argued that the anti-Muslim bias overwhelms any apparent national security concerns that appear in the president's proclamation.
|
|
I am surprised this is regarded as settled law in light of the vehement dissents, especially by Chief Justice John Roberts.
|
|
"I wish other people were joining me in my dissents, I'll say that," Kashkari said in a phone interview with Reuters.
|
|
Justices Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas noted their dissents, but it was unclear how Roberts or Justice Samuel Alito had voted.
|
|
As a lawyer, Ginsburg won important cases, and as a liberal justice in a conservative time, she has written stirring dissents.
|
|
Ho and Judge Don Willett, also confirmed in January 2018, wrote dissents explaining why they believed the court should rehear the case.
|
|
Despite not authoring many dissents, he earned the nickname "The Great Dissenter" for his pithy and succinct way of conveying his opinion.
|
|
Let us stand up to show our discontent on this abduction and stop the further suppression to political dissents in Hong Kong.
|
|
As was the case in the same-sex marriage ruling, Scalia was much better known for such biting dissents than groundbreaking rulings.
|
|
Those three dissents came from members who preferred to raise rates now, indicating clear pressure from within the central bank to act.
|
|
Ginsburg has indeed produced forcefully written dissents, especially as the Court has moved to the right, but they are not themselves immoderate.
|
|
Instead, the justices wrote lengthy opinions and dissents almost by rote, turning what had appeared to be routine cases into major disputes.
|
|
Seven Fed officials voted to leave rates unchanged while three voted for an increase, the largest bloc of dissents in several years.
|
|
The high court, with no recorded dissents, sent the case back to the lower court to reconsider whether special elections are necessary.
|
|
So in the three major cases that came to the court since 20123, Scalia opined against gay rights in sometimes brutal dissents.
|
|
In the time since, Barrett has authored dozens of opinions and dissents that offer fertile ground for her supporters and opposition researchers.
|
|
Three people voted against the decision to cut rates in September, the most dissents since Jerome H. Powell became chair last year.
|
|
These cases were decided 5-4 or 6-3 over angry dissents and with Justice Anthony Kennedy joining his more liberal colleagues.
|
|
In occasional dissents, for instance, Mr. Moore voiced support for overhauling sentencing laws that some say are too harsh and too rigid.
|
|
In the years after Holmes's death, his two most famous dissents—Lochner and Abrams—became cardinal principles in the transformed Supreme Court.
|
|
Others praise her for her stinging dissents as the leading liberal on a Supreme Court that now leans definitively to the right.
|
|
Judging by his concurrences and dissents, often joined by no other justice, he is not much interested in compromise, persuasion or coalition building.
|
|
The decision drew dissents from Boston Fed President Eric Rosengren and Kansas City Fed President Esther George who argued for leaving rates unchanged.
|
|
It is unhelpful in the extreme, therefore, for Supreme Court opinions (or dissents) to treat other points of view as unworthy of respect.
|
|
His dissents have often led to Supreme Court appeals, and the justices have repeatedly embraced the positions set out in Judge Kavanaugh's opinions.
|
|
While Scalia gleefully and imaginatively attacked identity politics, justices like Alito and Roberts were more muted (and less meme-worthy) in their dissents.
|
|
In two oft-cited dissents from 2011 and 2015, Kavanaugh argued against striking down elements of former President Barack Obama's signature health legislation.
|
|
Slaughter's forceful dissents in tech cases have also surprised some FTC observers given her previous role as a behind-the-scenes congressional staffer.
|
|
Gore, the court shut down the recount of votes in Florida in an unsigned opinion over the dissents of the four more liberal justices.
|
|
Swonk said if there are two dissents, it would be seen by the markets as a sign there may not be further rate cuts.
|
|
Both dissents in Poe are worth reading and provide further evidence that the right to privacy has deep roots in the American constitutional tradition.
|
|
Even some of the Hongkongers acted as dissents to voice out their disagreement towards the Communist Party of China, they would not face penalties.
|
|
The Supreme Court's unsigned summary opinion, with no noted dissents, didn't elaborate on the justices' reasoning to uphold the ruling of the lower court.
|
|
We have years of scholarship, theorizing, and amicus briefs, and a "jurisprudence in exile" of minority dissents that could easily turn into majority opinions.
|
|
Since joining the Court, she has written two dissents a term, on average, fewer than any other Justice except Kavanaugh in his first term.
|
|
Kevin Ring is the president of Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) and editor of Scalia's Court: A Legacy of Landmark Opinions and Dissents (Regnery).
|
|
His concurring opinions and dissents have long offered an unorthodox view of the court's precedents and practices that set him apart from his colleagues.
|
|
In my new book, Scalia's Court: A Legacy of Landmark Opinions and Dissents, I explain Scalia's approach to interpreting the Constitution and federal statutes.
|
|
As the LGBT movement took its case to the highest Court, Scalia wrote a number of salient dissents beginning in 1996 with Romer v.
|
|
The opinion is one of Judge Garland's rare dissents from a majority ruling, which was written by a judge nominated by President Bill Clinton.
|
|
It only means they did not choose to pen dissents of their own, sign Justice Sotomayor's dissent, or make a note of their votes.
|
|
The court's summary affirmance of the ruling to strike down the North Carolina voting districts gave no reasons, and there were no noted dissents.
|
|
Kevin Ring is the president of Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) and editor of "Scalia's Court: A Legacy of Landmark Opinions and Dissents" (Regnery).
|
|
In December, the Supreme Court allowed the latest travel ban to take effect while the case moved forward, with only two justices noting dissents.
|
|
Last term, he wrote two solo dissents — not his usual practice — to warn against what he sees as a words-on-the-page capitulation.
|
|
But Thomas's dissents, including last year's complaint about the court's "continued refusal to hear Second Amendment cases," suggested that it was a conscious decision.
|
|
That alone is enough to make the settlement unsatisfactory to the FTC's Rohit Chopra, who voted against the Facebook deal and also dissents today.
|
|
And on the issues he cared the most about – abortion, above all – his defeats were famous and his dissents often not just eloquent but anguished.
|
|
The two gentlemen represent central banking's answer to the "Last of the Mohicans," the sole two dissents that have been recorded by governors since 1995.
|
|
She has said in public appearances she chooses to read dissents from the bench only when she believes that a majority's opinion is particularly egregious.
|
|
Thomas dissents Justice Clarence Thomas, joined in part by Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, said he would have allowed the question on the census.
|
|
In one sentence, with no dissents, the Supreme Court declined to intervene, upholding the appeals-court ruling, which included a rollback of early voting days.
|
|
Kavanaugh has been skeptical of the ACA and its individual mandate in the past and wrote dissents in two cases that challenged the law's constitutionality.
|
|
Their vociferous dissents to the 2015 FCC's order, and every public comment they have made since, indicates they are not changing their mind on this.
|
|
The Fed's policy decision drew dissents from Boston Fed President Eric Rosengren and Kansas City Fed President Esther George who argued for leaving rates unchanged.
|
|
In two separate cases, Kavanaugh's dissents in finding certain EPA regulations exceeded their statutory limits were upheld in 5-4 opinions written by Justice Scalia.
|
|
The court's ruling on the Texas and Ohio cases elicited scathing dissents from Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the only Latina justice, about the costs to democracy.
|
|
Ginsburg's dissents continue to energize Democrats, at a time when Republicans control the executive and legislative branches of government and the Supreme Court moves rightward.
|
|
Even when the court has denied Mr Trump's requests, the more conservative justices have often penned dissents to explain why they should have been granted.
|
|
Justice Elena Kagan, a liberal and the author of one of those dissents, followed up with questions exploring how Monday's case might present different issues.
|
|
Meanwhile, Justice Thomas soared in his ensuing 25 years on the bench, issuing landmark rulings and dissents and exerting a profound influence on American law.
|
|
" However, in their separate dissents, Justice Stephen Breyer raised serious concerns about the waiver process, and Justice Sonia Sotomayor argued that it was a "sham.
|
|
Previous meetings had featured dissents from as many as three members who felt the Fed should resume a rate-hiking cycle it began in December 2015.
|
|
There are also several new pages in the proposal's appendix, but those are mostly statements and dissents that the commissioners issued during the vote last week.
|
|
She has mainly seen eye-to-eye with her colleagues: of the 46 opinions she has written on three-judge panels, only three have been dissents.
|
|
"We believe that Fed Chair Powell will want to counter the hawkish message sent from dissents," Bank of America economists wrote in a note on Friday.
|
|
This has prompted a series of scathing dissents from Commissioner Richard Glick, a former Democratic Senate aide whom President Trump appointed to the commission in 25.
|
|
That dissents from these propositions are so rare raises a basic question: How do we judge whether a country exhibits "strength" or "weakness" in world affairs?
|
|
I advise them to read every opinion, including dissents, the judge has ever written as well as important recent cases from the circuit and Supreme Court.
|
|
TWO 'NO' VOTES The decision drew dissents from Boston Fed President Eric Rosengren and Kansas City Fed President Esther George who argued for leaving rates unchanged.
|
|
Her dissents this term came mostly in criminal cases, informed as much by events in Ferguson, Mo., in 2014 as by those in Philadelphia in 1787.
|
|
WASHINGTON — Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's indignant dissents from the bench have turned her into a heroine of the left, beloved for methodically skewering her conservative colleagues.
|
|
But that started to change in the last decade, as conservatives on the court more aggressively asserted their philosophy and Justice Ginsburg began reading fiery dissents.
|
|
"The minimal size of the cut, the dissents, and Powell's press conference disappointed markets, and undercut our expectation," said Morgan Stanley analysts in a research report.
|
|
Villeroy, who rarely dissents in public, joins Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann, Austria's Robert Holzmann and Dutch central bank Governor Klaas Knot in criticising the bond buys.
|
|
The justices gave no explanation for denying the request that was submitted by the company, and there were no notable dissents from the nine-member court.
|
|
Villeroy, who rarely dissents in public, joins Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann, Austria's Robert Holzmann and Dutch central bank governor Klaas Knot in criticising the bond buys.
|
|
But two of his key dissents in cases related to reproductive rights indicate he could become a sympathetic ear to legal challenges over abortion access and contraception.
|
|
Those dissents illustrate the divide on the Fed board that has shown up in conflicting comments from Fed officials and could add to volatility in the markets.
|
|
By the time he retired after a nearly 20-year tenure, he stood out for his trenchant dissents protesting the conservative majority, in cases from Bush v.
|
|
Republican Commissioners Ajit Pai and Michael O'Rielly issued lengthy dissents of the final proposal before Democratic Commissioners Jessica Rosenworcel, Mignon Clyburn and Wheeler voted to pass it.
|
|
He is also a reliable ally of traditional communications incumbents in the telecom and media sector, who have relied on his sparkling, but oh-so-sound, dissents.
|
|
Cartoon by Roz Chast At the same time, because Kagan rarely writes stinging dissents like the one in the gerrymandering case, they can carry a potent charge.
|
|
The panel eventually broke down partisan lines — the 6 FCIC officials chosen by Democrats issued the official report, while the four Republican commissioners issued two separate dissents.
|
|
Sotomayor's dissents consistently reflect deep comprehension of the grave threats to democracy that we see today and an awareness of the injustices still faced by minority communities.
|
|
She does look frail at times and moves slowly, the last to leave the bench, but the frailty dissipates when she asks questions or crafts her dissents.
|
|
Her dissents in recent years have continued to energize Democrats at a time when Republicans control the executive branch of government and the Supreme Court moves rightward.
|
|
Those qualities resonate powerfully in the dissents that may prove to be Justice Ginsburg's most enduring legacy, and "RBG" is, above all, a tribute to her voice.
|
|
And in his George Mason speech, Kavanaugh highlighted two of Scalia's most controversial dissents on those topics, without either praising his opinions or raising concerns about them.
|
|
His efforts ranged from filing detailed dissents articulating the flaws in the proposed regulation, to raising awareness of the FCC danger through the media and - yes - tweets.
|
|
WASHINGTON — Justice Antonin Scalia could be caustic in his dissents, but he was also known for a sharp wit that often drew laughter from Supreme Court audiences.
|
|
The circuit turned decidedly to the right during the administrations of Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush, and many of Judge Wald's most important opinions were dissents.
|
|
In an official video released on Sunday, she accuses an unspecified "they" (presumably Democratic elites) of organizing to "destroy" and "discredit" anyone who dissents from their official line.
|
|
The rate cut saw two dissents, with Fed presidents Esther L. George of Kansas City and Eric Rosengren of Boston casting no votes, as many observers had expected.
|
|
His dissents could be intemperate and frankly insulting of his colleagues, and in recent years, he sometimes even suggested that he believed they were acting in bad faith.
|
|
The mood was so divisive that on the 24 term's penultimate day, two decisions on immigration and abortion prompted liberal justices to read three dissents from the bench.
|
|
Even as Fed officials have begun to speak more frequently and openly in public, formal dissents against any given policy action have in general declined since the 1970s.
|
|
Justice Samuel Alito joined only one of Thomas's dissents—in Garza, the Sixth Amendment case—and explicitly refused to join the portion disavowing the 1960s precedents under fire.
|
|
Earlier requests for stays were rejected over the dissents of two or three of the court's conservative members — Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel A. Alito and Neil M. Gorsuch.
|
|
Such dramatic oral dissents typically occur later in the session, when tensions rise as the court faces a late June deadline and highly anticipated cases with national implications.
|
|
Justice Gorsuch's first consequential vote was to deny a stay of execution to death row inmates in Arkansas over the dissents of the court's four-member liberal bloc.
|
|
The Democratic dissents may be particularly vexing for Simons, who has shown signs of being even more interested than past chairmen in winning unanimous decisions in major cases.
|
|
Trump is vowing to choose justices in the mold of the late Justice Antonin Scalia, whose virulent dissents against LGBTQ rights is clearly not what Lambda has in mind.
|
|
" Stevens later explained to CNN the importance of his dissents and commentary into his late 90s: "Sometimes the country may rethink problems and may come to a different conclusion.
|
|
Her dissents in recent years have continued to energize Democrats at a time when Republicans control the executive and legislative branches of government and the Supreme Court moves rightward.
|
|
The problem with this decision, as Justices Sotomayor and Neil Gorsuch argued in separate dissents, is that the "exigent circumstances" argument was not fully litigated in the lower courts.
|
|
The Times analyzed more than 10,000 published decisions and dissents since Mr. Trump took office and found that his appointees continued to stand out after they joined the bench.
|
|
And because there will be more and more judges like Ho on the federal bench, it's only a matter of time before such opinions will no longer be dissents.
|
|
In an unsigned opinion with no noted dissents, the court vacated an appeals court ruling that had allowed the teenager to obtain the procedure, saying the dispute was moot.
|
|
They tend to focus instead on the kind of knowledge that dissents from popular as much as authoritative opinion, instead of merely replacing it with a more "correct" one.
|
|
In the unsigned opinion with no dissents, the justices threw out the lower court decision on the grounds that the dispute became moot once the teenager had the abortion.
|
|
Were Mr. Trump to replace all three, the court's remaining liberals — Justices Sonia Sotomayor, 62, and Elena Kagan, 56 — could find themselves writing lonely dissents for years to come.
|
|
The feature provides unprecedented access to the pop culture icon known for her viral dissents and was made with the care and humor it deserves by an all-female crew.
|
|
For now, the expectation is that Powell's vision will win out, but he looks to be losing support, and a few dissents at July's meeting may be just the beginning.
|
|
Danielle DiMartino Booth, a former advisor to the Dallas Fed and president of Money Strong, said Yellen would have gotten three dissents regardless of whether or not she raised rates.
|
|
Despite three dissents, Chief Justice John Roberts joined the majority decision, indicating that he may be a swing vote in protecting same-sex marriage in the not too distant future.
|
|
Quinn to detail the decision's flaws, with an eye toward eventually overturning it in full (which the Court's liberals warned in dissents in those cases was his eventual game plan).
|
|
That's how our rule of law – forged with the deep principles and convictions of justices, and laid out in majority decisions and minority dissents – becomes the model for the world.
|
|
These opinions represent different groups — a unanimous court, a majority of the court, dissents from with the majority decision and even opinions that concur in part and dissent in part.
|
|
In the unsigned opinion with no dissents, the court said a dispute with the Justice Department became moot once the unnamed teenager obtained the abortion with assistance from her attorneys.
|
|
And in 1974, the Supreme Court crafted a unanimous ruling in the Watergate tapes case out of fear that Richard Nixon would use any dissents to justify ignoring the court.
|
|
In recent years, she has begun reading those dissents from the bench — as she did in the landmark Ledbetter case, an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) case on pay discrimination.
|
|
Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. said the court had been "lectured pretty sternly in a couple of dissents" in two recent cases in which its conservative majority had overturned precedents.
|
|
"Ideologically there are many things CAP had concerns about, including the way he interpreted the law, but I would say it was always interesting to read his dissents," she said.
|
|
"Investors had braced for the worst - from no rate hike to dissents and a change in the risk assessment," said Kathy Lien, managing director of currency strategy at BK Asset Management.
|
|
Fed speakers will also be watched carefully in the week ahead, after the Fed reached its agreement to hold rates steady with a surprising number of dissents from three Fed presidents.
|
|
Justice Ginsburg's oeuvre of elegant dissents is a reminder that the Supreme Court did not suddenly become conservative when Donald Trump's two picks landed in their chairs in 22019 and 21970.
|
|
In dissents, Commissioners Rohit Chopra and Rebecca Slaughter said they believed the fines were far too small, and that the FTC wrongfully gave Zuckerberg and Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg a pass.
|
|
Our reporter examines Justice Sonia Sotomayor's dissents and finds a jurist who is skeptical of the criminal justice system, with a perspective not unlike that of the Black Lives Matter movement.
|
|
Bloggers and other fans tagged her with the moniker Notorious RBG (a play on the late rapper Notorious B.I.G.) and have celebrated everything from her liberal dissents to iron-pumping workouts.
|
|
He has written few important majority opinions, but his concurrences and dissents present a rigorous and consistent judicial philosophy rooted in what he says is the original meaning of the Constitution.
|
|
Spera said she hopes that within a few decades, more of her grandmother's dissenting opinions will be adopted as majority opinions and eventually into law, like some of her past dissents.
|
|
There were no public dissents from the Court's order, although it is possible that one or more justices voted not to grant the stay but decided to keep that vote private.
|
|
Once on the bench, the Trump appointees have stood out from their fellow judges, according to an analysis by The Times of more than 10,20003 published decisions and dissents through December.
|
|
Meanwhile, the question of whether Democrats should try to cast out every single person who dissents from every important item on the progressive agenda is a lot bigger than the primary.
|
|
Last week, the court stayed the execution of a Buddhist inmate in Texas in similar circumstances, over two noted dissents, with the majority apparently satisfied that the request had been timely.
|
|
There were no noted dissents to the order, and it suggested that the justices were looking for a way to reach consensus on a subject that has divided them in the past.
|
|
"RBG" reveals a lot about the jurist known as the Notorious RBG for her fierce dissents from conservative rulings on so-called "partial-birth" abortion, contraceptive care, campaign finance and voting rights.
|
|
Well-written, well-reasoned opinions and dissents are necessary for lower courts if they are to follow Supreme Court precedent and help the public understand the role and logic of the Court.
|
|
The justices did us one small favor this term: Their decisions were clear and conclusive, and they lacked the overlapping partial concurrences and dissents that can make discerning the governing principle elusive.
|
|
"For the first time in at least ten years we've seen two or more dissents in three straight meetings," Ian Lyngan, BMO's head of U.S. rates, said in a note on Tuesday.
|
|
Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway show that these scientists have not limited their scientific dissents to climate-related issues; they have also argued against the adverse health effects of tobacco smoke.
|
|
The dissents come from a series of 3-2 party-line votes that mark a break with tradition for the FTC, a once-sleepy agency whose institutional culture has long emphasized consensus.
|
|
But more than that, the dissents lay the groundwork for a profound shift in how the commission approaches the giants of the tech industry, should it eventually go back to Democratic control.
|
|
In an unsigned order with no noted dissents, the court declined to take up Boise's appeal to reinstate its law allowing officers to ticket individuals sleeping and camping on sidewalks and parks.
|
|
The long-serving justice preferred peppery prose to legalistic jargon, and it shows with his longer dissents, opinions and his short "ninograms," which were little memos sent to his colleagues on the bench.
|
|
The dissents didn't hinge on the criminal/civil distinction at all, Gorsuch argued it shouldn't really exist, and the liberals argued that it exists but deportation is an exception that deserves special scrutiny.
|
|
As those law school casebooks began acquiring a more serious intellectual rigor, they also began filling up with his writings -- at first dissents, but then a healthy dose of majority opinions and concurrences.
|
|
In the meantime, Leo said, every slot matters, since conservative judges on liberal-majority courts can offer critical dissents in important cases and serve a kind of signaling function to the Supreme Court.
|
|
He opposed abortion and same-sex marriage, supported the death penalty and gun rights, and was known for colorful writing and, when he was on the losing end of a ruling, stinging dissents.
|
|
There are about 36 law clerks each term, and they offer recommendations on which cases to hear, help prepare the justices for oral arguments and draft major portions of the opinions and dissents.
|
|
We can expect people to actually act preemptively and pass laws that will go into effect when the newly constituted Court overturns Roe (no doubt with strong dissents from Ginsburg, Sotomayor, and Kagan).
|
|
JAMES R. OESTREICH from the start Another of my favorite "Star-Spangled Banner" dissents is Drew Baker's "National Anthem," composed in 2006 and available in a moving recording by the pianist Marilyn Nonken.
|
|
" Kavanaugh said in his 2016 speech that those two dissents are a sign of how Scalia believed that courts had "no legitimate role ... in creating new rights not spelled out in the Constitution.
|
|
Trump judges have made the situation even worse, most recently in an 8th Circuit decision that partly struck down a state lobbyist registration and disclosure law, despite dissents by two conservative Bush judges.
|
|
Elite U.S. tech workers, some awakened to political organizing by the election of President Trump, are increasingly giving their own CEOs a painful wakeup call via internal dissents on company business decisions and policies.
|
|
He's written key opinions and dissents on a host of topics shaping the world we live in, establishing deeply conservative views on everything from voting rights to net neutrality to immigrants to executive power.
|
|
Some strategists haves said the more dissents, the more it would add to increased market volatility, since the Fed outlook becomes much more uncertain if Fed officials are not more uniformly supporting policy actions.
|
|
On Monday, in an unsigned opinion without noted dissents, the Supreme Court said the trial court had acted too hastily and ordered it to reconsider the matter of whether a special election was warranted.
|
|
But in 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court, in an unsigned ruling with no dissents, overturned that holding, finding it was inconsistent with a 2008 Supreme Court decision declaring an individual's right to bear arms.
|
|
The Fed's decision last month to cut its policy target rate by a quarter of a percentage point, to a range of between 1.75% and 2.0%, drew three dissents out of 10 total votes.
|
|
While the opinions in Griswold may seem a little thin, that's partly because both Douglas and Harlan had stated their views in much more detail four years earlier in their dissents in Poe v. Ullman.
|
|
Although Scalia prevailed in many areas, thanks in part to the court's conservative majority during his tenure, he also was known for his colorful and angry dissents, often read with theatrical flair in the courtroom.
|
|
One source puts the pre-money price talk at around $3 billion (another dissents), which could mean the final investment is smaller if either side becomes concerned about CFIUS approvals (which I'd think they would).
|
|
In an unsigned opinion with no dissents, the justices said that the challengers failed to reach the high bar of showing "irreparable harm" that would be necessary for a preliminary injunction to block the map.
|
|
When asked about the two dissents at his press conference on Wednesday, Powell told reporters "there's a range of views on the committee" about the prospects of the economy and the future of monetary policy.
|
|
The town has a long history of Nonconformism, a form of Protestantism that dissents from the established Church of England, but modern-day Lewes seems more attached to the trappings of sectarianism than its reality.
|
|
" In an unsigned opinion with no noted dissents, the Supreme Court sent the Alaska case back to the Ninth Circuit, instructing it to "revisit whether Alaska's contribution limits are consistent with our First Amendment precedents.
|
|
The dynamics of the court could change in many subtle ways — producing, for example, more sharp dissents that catch the attention of the Supreme Court, said Leonard Leo, the executive vice president of the Federalist Society.
|
|
"There were three dissents, but the market has been jawboned into believing the Fed will raise rates in December," said Bill Northey, chief investment officer of the private client group at U.S. Bank in Helena, Montana.
|
|
Admirers have recently nicknamed her "Notorious RBG," a play on the late rapper Notorious B.I.G., and have hailed her as a bulwark against conservative ideology -- and President Donald Trump -- because of her liberal opinions and dissents.
|
|
That and last term's gerrymandering opinion account for two of the three dissents that she has read from the bench—a choice that Justices make infrequently and deliberately, to emphasize how vital they consider the issue.
|
|
Sanders said that on the whole, most of Barrett's opinions have been fairly innocuous; in 49 opinions and several dissents, Barrett has touched on abortion only once and has yet to write directly about religious liberty.
|
|
Two of the commissioners penned strong dissents noting concern over how the incorrect statement was not material to consumers and worrying that the FTC's action discourages companies to provide opt-outs or even meaningful privacy policies.
|
|
The Obama administration also prevented the reappointment of Jennifer Hillman, an American and former U.S. trade official, out of concern she was not being aggressive enough in issuing dissents in rulings that attacked American trade laws.
|
|
Justice Elena Kagan read from her dissent on behalf of the four more liberal justices, beginning her comments bluntly — "There is no sugarcoating today's opinion" — and taking a tone most closely resembling some of Scalia's heated dissents.
|
|
Since they've already taken the step [to cut rates], they'll probably take another, but his comments and the two dissents suggest this is not the beginning of a major easing cycle and that's what hammered the market.
|
|
Her concurring statements were always cheerful and gracious (though often cautious regarding certain aspects of a proposal) and her dissents were fiery and unsparing; you can read some choice words on the controversial net neutrality order here.
|
|
In a pair of unusually blunt dissents in recent cases involving Facebook and Google, Rohit Chopra and Rebecca Kelly Slaughter argued for much tougher financial penalties for companies that break their promises and abuse their users' privacy.
|
|
He defined those issues as cases from the past eight years that overruled precedent and included dissents, cases on novel legal issues and any other case that a regional office believes will be important to the general counsel.
|
|
His dissents, particularly the ones he has written solo, tend to be fascinating and weird, eschewing traditional legal arguments for enthusiastic and lengthy historical surveys of the habits and cultural mores that might have informed the Founding Fathers.
|
|
That same day, the Supreme Court -- again over public dissents from Thomas and Gorsuch -- rejected a Trump administration request to block a lawsuit by youths who want to hold the government responsible for emissions policy and climate change.
|
|
Judge Kavanaugh's opinions for that court — and his numerous concurrences and dissents — reveal more clearly than any other potential source how the nominee thinks about the kinds of legal issues he would confront as a Supreme Court justice.
|
|
In a unsigned opinion with no noted dissents from any of the nine justices, the high court directed the San Francisco-based 22016th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to reconsider the case because of Judge Stephen Reinhardt's death.
|
|
After what has often appeared to be intense behind-the-scenes negotiations, Chief Justice Roberts has so far assembled coalitions that mostly denied the requests, often over the dissents of two or three of his most conservative colleagues.
|
|
Miscimarra's many dissents in NLRB cases since his appointment in 2013 helped lay the foundation for claims by the business community that under Obama, the board baldly favored unions rather than promoting a balance between labor and management.
|
|
Word of the Day noun: a person who dissents from some established policy adjective: characterized by departure from accepted beliefs or standards adjective: disagreeing, especially with a majority _________ The word dissident has appeared in 208 articles on nytimes.
|
|
"The downward move in the dollar is interesting and notable in the sense that the only dovish thing I see in this meeting is the two dissents," said Erik Nelson, a currency strategist at Wells Fargo in New York.
|
|
Laurie L. Levenson, a professor at Loyola Law School, said that it was unlikely that the court would take the case because there were no dissents among the panel of judges and the court affirmed there was sufficient evidence.
|
|
Chopra and Slaughter issued loud dissents in two recent, headline-making tech cases: the $5 billion settlement in July with Facebook over privacy violations and this month's $170 million fine for Google's YouTube over its handling of children's data.
|
|
"The partisanship is pretty striking, and the string of partisan dissents is a pretty big departure from tradition at the FTC," said one Obama administration official who worked on competition issues and spoke anonymously to discuss intra-party differences.
|
|
Some 21 other cases received partial dissents, meaning the commissioners agreed to proceed with the case but disagreed on matters like whether to require shareholders to bear the costs of paying a corporate penalty, or whether the evidence justified specific charges.
|
|
A glance at Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai's dissents when he was a commissioner during the Obama administration demonstrates how valuable even minority opinions can be in helping to shape board decisions and highlighting when the majority reaches too far.
|
|
"The presence of two political appointees on the board may mean more dissents and discordant communication, but the remainder of the board will have sufficient numbers to conduct monetary policy based on the dual mandate, as opposed to political preference."
|
|
Health issues for the justice, a liberal who has become a feminist icon in recent years thanks to her fiery dissents and her work on women's rights, have led to questions about how long she will remain on the bench.
|
|
The final tally among the 10 voting members saw three dissents from Fed presidents – Eric Rosengren of Boston and Esther George of Kansas City, who favored holding the line, and James Bullard of St. Louis who wanted a half-point cut.
|
|
When the Fed met this week and raised short-term interest rates for the fifth time since late 2015, the inflation issue triggered two dissents among the nine voters on the policy-setting Federal Open Market Committee, and that division could widen.
|
|
At one point in the speech, Kavanaugh singled out two of Scalia's most controversial dissents, in cases upholding same-sex marriage and abortion rights, to show how the late justice argued against creating rights for individuals not spelled out in the Constitution.
|
|
While on the Supreme Court, the justices took turns delivering scathing dissents on one another's opinions -- but off the bench they shared a New Year's Eve dinner tradition, traveled internationally, and bonded over a mutual love of music, Scalia told Harlow and Toobin.
|
|
In an order that did not list any dissents, the court denied a request to stay a lower court ruling that held the company in contempt and forced it to pay $50,000 a day in fines until it complied with the subpoena.
|
|
Janet Yellen garnered 22 votes in opposition across a total of 31 interest-rate setting policy meetings while she was chair and there were 58 dissents under Ben Bernanke's chairmanship over the course of 65 meetings under Presidents George W. Bush and then Obama.
|
|
Yet today, with some notable dissents in both countries, those interpretations remain as frozen in history as the shadow etched on the stone steps of a bank building near ground zero — created by the body of a poor soul who was sitting there at detonation.
|
|
Both Lower Courts and Congress Need to Address Other Advanced Surveillance Techniques The Court's decision may well be disruptive as Justice Kennedy and Justice Alito allude to in their dissents, but that is because privacy laws have failed to keep pace with changing technologies.
|
|
As I've said before: Art you can take home in a taxi dissents from the big scale and site specificity that, regardless of medium, are so highly favored if not fetishized by the current system of huge spaces, museum commissions and sprawling international exhibitions.
|
|
On Monday, the justices, in an opinion with no recorded dissents throwing out the decision requiring special elections, said the lower court gave only a "cursory" analysis of whether such elections were "a proper remedy for a racial gerrymander" when it ordered them last November.
|
|
" Michelle Meyer, Bank of America Merrill Lynch: Ms. Meyer says she expects the Fed raise rates this meeting, but "unlike December where there were two dissents, we expect this decision to be unanimous given the shift in voters this year in the hawkish direction.
|
|
Instead, Justice Anthony Kennedy's decision for the court only drew dissents from two justices by focusing on the fact that, as he put it, Phillips was treated with "hostility" by Colorado's Civil Rights Commission — action that the Supreme Court ruled violates the First Amendment's Free Exercise Clause.
|
|
The two dissents were expected and do not give much signal on future action....If the Chair could not pull the Committee to 50bp today or even a strongly dovish tilt, we see it as unlikely that he can pull them to cuts in subsequent meetings.
|
|
"Though his rulings, votes, and dissents were often infuriating to liberal Americans, his fellow jurist Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who was a friend as well as a coworker, explained to the Wall Street Journal in 2014, "Scalia is often criticized by people who would not be labeled conservative.
|
|
The Fed's policy decision drew dissents from Boston Fed President Eric Rosengren and Kansas City Fed President Esther George who argued for leaving rates unchanged in the face of the current economic expansion, an unemployment rate that is near a 50-year-low, and robust household spending.
|
|
This was an easy message to counter, especially given the extreme nature of the Left's position — that grown men have a civil right to shower with young women, and that any business or organization that dissents from this view should be removed from the public square.
|
|
During three decades on the federal bench, through December 22002, Judge Noonan heard oral arguments in 224,21926 cases and wrote 219,19663 opinions, dissents and other decisions in longhand on yellow legal pads — most notably a 21966 ruling upholding a Washington State law banning physician-assisted suicide.
|
|
Powell may want to nod to dissenters' concerns and signal that this may not be the first in a long series of cuts, or he may want to counteract the dissents and strongly reinforce a "dovish" Fed outlook, meaning one more biased to cutting rates than a "hawkish" stance.
|
|
Played by British actress Felicity Jones, the Ruth we see in On The Basis Of Sex isn't the mythic figure known today as "The Notorious RBG," the octogenarian legend whose fiery dissents are shared on social media, and whose image is tattooed on body parts and feminist bumper stickers.
|
|
The nine justices, with no noted dissents, declined to hear an appeal by abortion provider Planned Parenthood of a lower court ruling that had revived the 2015 state law, which sets regulations regarding the RU-20133 "abortion pill," after it was earlier struck down by a federal judge.
|
|
NEW YORK (Reuters) - A divided federal appeals court on Thursday said American Muslims who landed on the "No-Fly List" because of their refusal to become government informants can sue FBI agents for damages, prompting dissents that said the decision was dangerous and defied U.S. Supreme Court precedents.
|
|
Powell's predecessor Janet Yellen drew 22 votes in opposition across a total of 31 interest-rate setting policy meetings while she was chair and there were 58 dissents under Ben Bernanke's chairmanship over the course of 65 meetings under Presidents George W. Bush and then President Barack Obama.
|
|
Clearly, even if the Heller decision is left alone (anyone who reads the dissents in Heller and McDonald will plainly see the liberal bloc of justices would like to reverse this ruling) there are big questions the Supreme Court will at some point have to answer about our Second Amendment freedoms.
|
|
It is in line with dissents over the years by Justices Brennan, Marshall, and Blackmun, not with the many majority opinions of the Supreme Court that have repeatedly upheld reasonable regulations that do not impose an undue burden on the abortion right recognized by the Supreme Court in Roe v. Wade.
|
|
Within minutes of Tuesday night's news that former Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens died after a stroke at age 99, seemingly all of Washington had anecdotes to share about the man known for his dissents and independence, his love of baseball, and his faith in judicial oversight of executive power.
|
|
But two administration officials argued that this claim misunderstands how the conservative legal movement has matured as the generation of Republican lawyers shaped by reading the originalist dissents of Justice Scalia and by the bitter 1987 fight over Judge Robert H. Bork's failed Supreme Court nomination has come of age.
|
|
Unfortunately for them, not only was the request denied, but some particularly absurd dissents from Judges Brown and Kavanaugh allowed the court to give the ruling a fresh coat of paint and further discredit the arguments against Title II. Kavanaugh argued that net neutrality infringed on the free speech rights… of internet providers.
|
|
The fact that such a situation does not trigger a number of dissents suggests the entire Fed has shifted, according to Crosby Kemper III, the executive director of the Kansas City Public Library and a former banker who touted Georges inflation-fighting credentials in a wide-ranging public interview with her in February.
|
|
The fact that such a situation does not trigger a number of dissents suggests the entire Fed has shifted, according to Crosby Kemper III, the executive director of the Kansas City Public Library and a former banker who touted George's inflation-fighting credentials in a wide-ranging public interview with her in February.
|
|
"Under the current oppressive political climate, there is legitimate fear that the law may be abused to stifle dissents, such as expressed in peaceful street protests which should have been a fundamental right to assemble," said Oh, who is currently an adjunct senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore.
|
|
RELATED: Ruth Bader Ginsburg's absence creates uncertainty about Supreme Court's present and future The justices are clearly moving gingerly, with Roberts, who cares about the integrity of the court more than any other justice, perhaps urging caution at times and maybe trying to limit -- if not eliminate -- any angry dissents from some of his colleagues.
|
|
"Burger Dissents; First Amendment Rule Held to Block Most Prior Restraints" (June 30, 19843) — view in TimesMachine In 1971, the Supreme Court, in a 6-3 decision, freed The New York Times and The Washington Post to resume immediate publication of articles based on the secret Pentagon Papers on the origins of the Vietnam War.
|
|
McFerran, who joined the five-member board in 2014, was the NLRB's last remaining appointee of former Democratic President Barack Obama and over the past year had issued a series of sharp dissents criticizing her three colleagues appointed by Republican President Donald Trump for issuing decisions and proposed rules that she said would disadvantage workers.
|
|
The social justice left, which is essentially a Marxist construct, has not just advanced an idea of the way the world is but has decided to instantly stigmatize and demonize anyone who dissents from it as a bigot and a racist or a homophobe and all the other litany of bullshit they throw around.
|
|
How can they sincerely object to a judge whose rulings have been endorsed by the Supreme Court more than a dozen times, whose thoughtful analysis in more than 300 published opinions has been routinely cited by other jurists across the nation, and whose concurrences and dissents have been discussed by more than 50 circuit courts in their own opinions?
|
|
Even as a 5-4 majority of the high court invalidated state laws defining marriage as the union between a man and a woman, both the majority opinion and the dissents proclaimed the court's belief that tolerance is — or should be — a two-way street, though they also revealed a certain dissonance about what tolerance demanded.
|
|
My colleagues Michael D. Shear and Julie Hirschfeld Davis, who had been in the courtroom, soon added a sense of what had happened there, focusing especially on the rare oral dissents delivered by Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. Then I spent perhaps an hour reading and another 90 minutes writing a full article that was posted in the early afternoon.
|
|
Based on his opinions and dissents over his 12 years on the bench, as well as other writings and activities over the years, Judge Kavanaugh's view of the Constitution and the law is so far outside the mainstream of American legal thinking and of society at large that he makes Antonin Scalia and Robert Bork look like centrists by comparison.
|
|
For example, Judge Stephen Williams wrote an opinion that concurs in part and dissents in part, but the only thing you really need to know about it is that it starts with a quote from Macbeth: And be these juggling fiends no more believed, That palter with us in a double sense; That keep the word of promise to our ear, And break it to our hope.
|
|
Starting with the things that we focus the most on, we are extremely concerned about some of the dissents that he wrote on the DC circuit court, starting with his dissent in the very, very publicized Jane Doe case in 2017, where the Trump administration was holding an undocumented woman in detention rather than releasing her to get the abortion that she needed and requested.
|
|
But Judge Kavanaugh has used such dissents to press his views to several audiences: to the Supreme Court, which pays close attention to them when deciding whether to hear an appeal; to litigants, who have pursued legal strategies that Judge Kavanaugh mapped out; and to the conservative legal movement, which got a detailed account of his views on legal issues not directly before him.
|
|
In an unsigned opinion with no noted dissents, the Supreme Court ordered the district court hearing the challenges to the Trump administration's DACA decision to first consider whether the decision of then-Acting Secretary of Homeland Security Elaine Duke to rescind DACA is reviewable and, if it is, whether the district court has jurisdiction to hear the case in light of restrictions in the Immigration and Nationality Act.
|
|
The Times examination was based on interviews with dozens of people close to the nomination process, including some of Mr. Trump's appointees; the analysis of thousands of published decisions and dissents since Mr. Trump became president; a review of detailed biographical and financial questionnaires submitted by all 168 appellate judges named by Mr. Trump, Mr. Obama and Mr. Bush, as well as their records, public statements and campaign contributions since 1989.
|
|
RELATED: Susan Collins defends her Brett Kavanaugh vote after he dissents in abortion access case Some believe that one reason that Roberts might have cast his vote with the liberals is because he wanted the case to come before the court on a non-emergency basis with plenty of time for the parties and the justices to consider the arguments and perhaps distinguish the Louisiana case from the Texas ruling.
|
|
The two Democrats on the commission, Mignon Clyburn and Jessica Rosenworcel, will likely file dissents, or minority reports detailing why, specifically, they disagree with the 200-page order (a draft of which was released last week.) And when they do, Pai and his two fellow Republican commissioners, Michael O'Rielly and Brendan Carr, will likely take some time to counter those concerns in print, if only in preparation for the long legal battle that lies ahead.
|
|
Kavanaugh established himself as a prominent conservative legal voice nationwide through his opinions and dissents about the limits of federal agency power — his writings in recent years included an opinion finding the structure of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau unconstitutional (he was later reversed by the full court); a dissent when his colleagues denied a request to reconsider upholding net neutrality rules; and a dissent when the court ruled that an undocumented teenager in US custody could get an abortion.
|
|
When de Kooning posits that "the status quo in the arts is fine as it is," Drexler dissents: What this woman who wrote the article may mean is there are people who manipulate the art world — who can decide by tumeling up business, by talking, by maybe buying articles, by collecting, by publishing — that they can build a reputation, and the people who do this may feel subliminally — no matter what they say — that they wouldn't do this for a woman, or, at least, not for many women.
|
|
In addition, a top Democratic senator dissents from growing party calls to abolish ICE A left-wing populist who fervently opposed President Trump's immigration policies won Mexico's presidential election Sunday night NBA superstar LeBron James agrees to four-year, $29 million blockbuster contract with the Los Angeles Lakers, once again leaving behind his hometown Cleveland Cavaliers THE LEAD STORY - FOX NEWS EXCLUSIVE - TRUMP ON SUPREME PICK, ROE V. WADE ... AND PUTTING DEMS ON ICE: President Trump expects his next Supreme Court pick "to go very quickly" and says he is unlikely to ask his nominee's position on the landmark Roe vs.
|
|