Women are dissenting from the national vote by their usual amount.
|
|
Kavanaugh issued an opinion dissenting from Thursday's decision to issue the stay.
|
|
Dissenting from that second ruling, Justice Breyer said he feared for the future.
|
|
Collin Peterson (D-MN) and Jeff Van Drew (D-NJ) dissenting from their party to vote no.
|
|
The court did not give any statement supporting or dissenting from its decision to reject the case.
|
|
Veteran bank analyst Richard Bove is dissenting from the Wall Street consensus over interest rate hikes. Why?
|
|
A few are actively dissenting from its mission, and trying to find ways to resist or subvert it.
|
|
But its largely symbolic decision marks yet another company dissenting from Facebook's hands-off approach to political ads.
|
|
In 2016, dissenting from the court's decision not to hear an earlier case on the issue, Justice Thomas expressed frustration.
|
|
A student official said he had seen posts on WeChat threatening to report students dissenting from the pro-China stance.
|
|
And I haven't forgotten his perfervid opinion dissenting from the court's 2015 decision declaring a constitutional right to same-sex marriage.
|
|
Dissenting from the Supreme Court's recent decision not to review California's 85033-day waiting period to purchase firearms in Silvester v.
|
|
In an opinion partially concurring with and partially dissenting from Justice Kagan's ruling, Justice Sotomayor warned the decision "will beget unfortunate results".
|
|
The judge was dissenting from a court order denying a new hearing in an earlier round of litigation on the travel ban.
|
|
Moreover, there is a distinction between failing to accept the outcome of an election and dissenting from certain political ideologies and rhetoric.
|
|
Dissenting from previous ways of seeing and interpreting Op and kinetic art, it aspires to cast these genres in a new and different light.
|
|
But he's governed as an increasingly straightforward right-winger, and gives no sign of dissenting from his party's unpopular stance on the tax issue.
|
|
Mr Sirechi "has lived in prison under threat of execution for 343 years", he wrote, dissenting from the court's refusal to hear his case.
|
|
And although, technically, Gorsuch was dissenting from that ruling against the criminal defendant for the government, that dissent was a concurrence in all but name.
|
|
Some include instances of employees dissenting from Microsoft's official stance on diversity and demanding more evidence that a diverse workforce is beneficial for the company.
|
|
Corporations are some of the most trusted institutions in our society, but conservatives are now loudly dissenting from most corporate-brokered models of social consensus.
|
|
Dissenting from the majority was Judge Josephine Staton, who usually presides over a federal trial court in California but was designated to the appellate case.
|
|
Bybee was dissenting from a Ninth Circuit decision stating that the court would not reconsider its February ruling putting Trump's original executive order on hold.
|
|
On Saturday the Group of 20 major economies failed to agree on fighting climate change, with Trump dissenting from a commitment to honor the Paris deal.
|
|
In 2016, Chief Justice John Roberts joined the conservatives in dissenting from the court's 5-3 decision to strike down the Texas version of the law.
|
|
All four took the unusual step of dissenting from the bench at various points, to underscore the dangerous turn they believed the court already was taking.
|
|
About 900 department officials signed a memo dissenting from the policy, a source familiar with the document said, an unusual rebellion against a new president's policies.
|
|
Dissenting from that ruling, Judge Danny J. Boggs wrote that the Michigan law had no partisan tilt and merely nudged voters to think a little more carefully.
|
|
And Justice Gorsuch joined an opinion by Justice Thomas, dissenting from the court's refusal to hear a challenge to California's restrictions on the concealed carrying of firearms.
|
|
After a Goldman analyst wrote an optimistic assessment of Countrywide's mortgage stock, a company due diligence officer responded with a cryptic email, apparently dissenting from the analyst's view.
|
|
In October, dissenting from a denial of a stay of execution in an opinion almost certainly written in haste, Justice Breyer got the date of an earlier decision wrong.
|
|
In 2003, for instance, dissenting from a decision striking down a Texas law that made gay sex a crime, Justice Scalia bemoaned the influence of elite culture on the law.
|
|
In February she took another hard line against a criminal defendant, dissenting from a ruling for a convict who complained that the state had withheld evidence favourable to his case.
|
|
Dissenting from one such order last month, Justice Sotomayor wrote that the administration had become too quick to run to the Supreme Court after interim losses in the lower courts.
|
|
Dissenting from the full court's decision not to rehear the case, Judge Frank H. Easterbrook, joined by three other judges, wrote that both parts of the panel's decision were misguided.
|
|
It includes proposals that critics say have the potential to erode Italy's representative democracy, such as banning members of Parliament from switching parties, or from dissenting from the party line.
|
|
More than 1,85033 State Department employees recently signed on to a cable dissenting from a White House order that temporarily halted all refugee resettlement and travel from seven Muslim-majority countries.
|
|
Last year, dissenting from the court's decision not to hear a Second Amendment case, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the court was abdicating its duty to protect an important constitutional right.
|
|
"Dishonest firms may come to conclude that posting fake reviews is a viable strategy, given the proposed outcome here," Chopra said in a statement dissenting from the FTC's decision, joined by Slaughter.
|
|
In dissenting from the court's majority, Justice Clarence Thomas said the case should have been remanded for a new trial because the jurors had a chance to mingle with the outside world.
|
|
People who felt he'd be a bad president felt secure in dissenting from the Democratic Party to either the right (Gary Johnson) or the left (Jill Stein) because everyone knew Clinton would win anyway.
|
|
One of the most prominent, recent examples of states dissenting from national law occurred when voters in Colorado, Washington, Alaska, Oregon and California made the use of marijuana legal, either medically and/or recreational.
|
|
"The fans showing up to hear Rush were the wrong kind of fans—the mockable ones, with mockable taste in music," Weigel writes, holding up this judgment for ridicule without quite dissenting from it.
|
|
"The president's efforts at the disruption of governance — his suspicion of a 'deep state' he professes to find in the bureaucracy — is what's coalescing all of these people dissenting from his administration," he said.
|
|
It would be nice to live in a more forgiving world, one where dissenting from groupthink does not invite exile and people's occasional lapses are not held up as evidence of who they are.
|
|
Consequently, the work of George Borjas, a Harvard Kennedy School professor who has produced the bulk of the research dissenting from the optimistic consensus, tends to play an outsize role in the media landscape.
|
|
She has been the most consistent among the liberal justices in dissenting from significant decisions crafted by conservative majorities, particularly this term (with Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the more familiar liberal icon, a close second).
|
|
" Dissenting from the full Ninth Circuit's refusal to reconsider the panel's decision, Judge Milan D. Smith Jr., joined by five colleagues, wrote that the ruling "has begun wreaking havoc on local governments, residents and businesses.
|
|
Sotomayor, in a strongly worded an 18-page opinion joined by fellow liberal Stephen Breyer dissenting from the court's refusal to hear the case, further exposed the rift among the eight justices over the death penalty.
|
|
In February, dissenting from the Supreme Court's decision not to hear an Alabama death row inmate's appeal, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that there is scientific and anecdotal evidence to question the use of midazolam in executions.
|
|
Instead, like almost all other states, it has opted for a "medically sterile aura of peace," as Justice Sotomayor wrote in February, dissenting from the court's decision not to hear a challenge to Alabama's use of midazolam.
|
|
OSAKA (Reuters) - After much wrangling, the Group of 20 major economies on Saturday agreed to disagree on fighting climate change, with the United States dissenting from a commitment to carry out the 2015 Paris climate change agreement.
|
|
Dissenting from the decision, conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch, said the decision is "not how antitrust law is supposed to work" because it gives a green light to the exact type of case that the court had previously prohibited.
|
|
Judge Kavanaugh often expressed his views in an unusual format, dissenting from the full (or en banc) court's decision not to rehear a case decided by a three-judge panel of which he had not been a member.
|
|
The state prosecutor's office, which has in recent months, been dissenting from the government over judicial matters, said 14 prisoners accused of destroying a statue of Chavez in western Zulia state should be judged in civilian not military courts.
|
|
Dissenting from his colleagues on the D.C. Circuit, he argued that the government's efforts violated the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and chastised the panel majority for "judicially second-guessing the correctness or the reasonableness" of the plaintiffs' religious beliefs.
|
|
In foreign countries without America's entrenched system of two-party politics, it is relatively common to find a political party that locates itself firmly on the right in most domestic matters while dissenting from the neoliberal consensus on globalization.
|
|
"Perhaps most troublingly, the Court's recent behavior on stay applications has benefited one litigant over all others," Sotomayor wrote in a sharp opinion dissenting from the court's decision to lift an injunction on the administration's immigrant "public charge" rule.
|
|
" Dissenting from the ruling, Judge John Clifford Wallace said that evidence provided by the state, including studies and surveys showing the use of large-capacity magazines increase the lethality of gun violence, "was more than sufficient to satisfy intermediate scrutiny.
|
|
In dissenting from the majority, Judge Barry Silverman said that the ordinance did not infringe upon anyone's right to bear arms and that "what we're dealing with here is a mundane zoning dispute dressed up as a Second Amendment challenge."
|
|
In dissenting from this ruling, Mr Kennedy embraced the position Justice Lewis Powell adopted in Regents v Bakke, the 1978 case that banned racial quotas but legitimised the use of race as a "plus factor" in pursuit of educational diversity.
|
|
Dissenting from the D.C. Circuit's ruling, Judge Kavanaugh concluded that provisions of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act insulating the PCAOB from the executive branch through a double for-cause removal structure violated the President's Article II authority to supervise the executive branch.
|
|
In Garza versus Idaho, Thomas was joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch in dissenting from the majority conclusion that a criminal defendant was denied effective assistance of counsel when his attorney did not pursue an appeal after being requested to do so.
|
|
Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) he even issued his own addendum dissenting from the official findings of the Republican majority, complaining that the Obama administration had "stonewalled" the committee by refusing to turn over key documents or allowing crucial witnesses to testify.
|
|
" Judge Paul V. Niemeyer of the Fourth Circuit, dissenting from last week's opinion, agreed, expressing alarm that in the future a court could "have free rein to select whichever expression of a candidate's developing ideas best supports its desired conclusion.
|
|
One camp wants Mrs May to sack Mr Johnson, who has been writing articles clearly dissenting from the government line; another camp wants to see the back of Philip Hammond, the chancellor, who is taking a cautious view of post-Brexit economic prospects.
|
|
In another case, the Washington Post noted, Kavanaugh ruled that the EPA should have to consider how much it costs for coal- and oil-fired power plants to reduce their emissions of toxic chemicals like mercury, dissenting from other justices who upheld the pollution standards.
|
|
"In my statement last year dissenting from the commission's decision, I warned that the FCC lacked the power to preempt these Tennessee and North Carolina laws and that doing so would usurp fundamental aspects of state sovereignty," said Ajit Pai, the commission's senior Republican member.
|
|
Secretary of State John KerryJohn Forbes KerryTrump's winning weapon: Time The Memo: O'Rourke looks to hit reset button #FreeAustinTice trending on anniversary of kidnapping in Syria MORE met with authors of a recent memo dissenting from the Obama administration's Syria policy, according to a spokesman.
|
|
For that very same political left, the marketplace of ideas now is to be closed to those dissenting from received wisdom, defined as the arguments and assumptions serving the left's political interests, particularly in the context of the great crusade of the day, man-made climate change.
|
|
On Monday, he issued an opinion dissenting from the court's refusal to hear a prisoner's complaint against the North Carolina prison system for failing to accommodate his wish to get together with fellow Jewish inmates for an hour every week to pray and study religious texts.
|
|
At the City University of New York, for example, a large faction of grad-student and adjunct workers is dissenting from (and angering) union leaders to push a bold #7KorStrike movement, which calls for a strike unless the university doubles their per-course pay from $3,500 to $7,000.
|
|
Dissenting from the full District of Columbia Circuit's decision not to rehear a three-judge panel's decision upholding the Obama administration's "net neutrality" regulations, he said the government can no more tell internet service providers what content to carry than it can tell bookstores what books they can sell.
|
|
Dissenting from a decision that upended a 40-year-old rule involving out-of-state lawsuits, Justice Breyer chastised his conservative colleagues for "surrender[ing] to the temptation" of overruling a precedent not because it has proved to be unworkable but simply because five justices happen to disagree with it.
|
|
The two judges who formed the Fifth Circuit majority also tried to show that the doctors could have obtained admitting privileges if only they had tried harder, a conclusion flatly refuted by the findings at trial but embraced by Justice Brett Kavanaugh in his opinion last week, dissenting from the Supreme Court's vote to grant a stay of the Fifth Circuit's decision.
|
|
Donald TrumpDonald John TrumpTrump pushes back on recent polling data, says internal numbers are 'strongest we've had so far' Illinois state lawmaker apologizes for photos depicting mock assassination of Trump Scaramucci assembling team of former Cabinet members to speak out against Trump MORE's cabinet nominees are dissenting from his views during their confirmation hearings — and that is just fine with those in the GOP who are skeptical of the president-elect.
|
|
The order had reportedly been drafted by Trump's White House advisers, led by Stephen K. Bannon and Stephen Miller, with only 11th-hour notification given to the government agencies that would be tasked with enforcing or defending it, or dealing with its geopolitical consequences: the Department of Homeland Security, the State Department (more than a hundred staff members of which have signed a memorandum dissenting from the order), the Department of Defense.
|
|
YouTube has also been criticised for suppressing opinions dissenting from governments' positions, especially related to the 2019 coronavirus pandemic.
|
|
Dissenting from the majority of her party, Bernini is fully favourable to the recognition of same-sex unions in Italy and to the stepchild adoption.
|
|
Universal Camera, 340 U.S. at 488. Justices Black and Douglas concurred only in parts I and II of the opinion, dissenting from part III.Universal Camera, 340 U.S. at 497.
|
|
Plaintiffs filed a petition for rehearing en banc. In August 2015, the petition was denied. Four judges dissented from the denial of rehearing. The judges wrote an opinion dissenting from the denial of rehearing and on the merits of Sissel's claim.
|
|
1366, 1367 (E.D.N.Y. 1971), aff'd, 454 F.2d 454 (2d Cir.), cert. denied, 406 U.S. 977 (1972); People v. Clayton, 279 N.Y.S.2d 605, 606 (App. Div. 2d Dep't 1967) (Christ, Acting P.J., dissenting from the affirmance of conviction), aff'd, 239 N.E.2d 734 (N.
|
|
In 2015, Torruella dissenting from a First Circuit decision denying Dzhokhar Tsarnaev's request for a writ of mandamus compelling the district court to grant a change of venue of Tsarnaev's trial due to widespread pretrial publicity.In re Tsarnaev, 780 F.3d 14 (1st Cir. 2015) (per curiam).
|
|
453 The case of Taylor v. Beckham was eventually appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States, but the court refused to intervene in the case because it found there were no federal questions involved. The lone justice dissenting from that opinion was Kentuckian John Marshall Harlan.
|
|
Gross, 135 S. Ct. 824 (2015) (Sotomayor, J., dissenting from denial of stays of execution). Oklahoma executed Warner later that day. However, on January 23, the Supreme Court decided to hear the case, staying the surviving petitioners' executions. The proceeding was then renamed, with Richard Glossip as lead petitioner.
|
|
She had input on several landmark case law decisions, sometimes dissenting from her colleagues. With her departure, only one woman (Christine Hohmann- Dennhardt) sat on the German First Senate. This led to a debate about whether women are still at a disadvantage in the German legal system.Süddeutsche Zeitung vom 5.
|
|
On April 3, 2006, the Supreme Court declined, with three justices dissenting from denial of certiorari, to hear Padilla's appeal from the 4th Circuit Court's decision. It left the 4th Circuit court's ruling that the president had the power to designate and detain him as an "enemy combatant" without charges and with disregard to habeas corpus.
|
|
United States (2014). In 2015, Gorsuch wrote a dissent to the denial of rehearing en banc when the Tenth Circuit found that a convicted sex offender had to register with Kansas after he moved to the Philippines.United States v. Nichols, 784 F. 3d 666, 667 (10th 2015) (Gorsuch, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc).
|
|
Dann v. Johnston, 450 U.S. 175 (1976). In dissenting from that judgment on the grounds that the Supreme Court in Benson did not limit the principle to method claims, Judge Rich spoke of "the legal doctrine that a new program makes an old general purpose digital computer into a new and different machine." Id. at 773.
|
|
He employed as chaplain Edmund Calamy, who had studied at Pembroke, already dissenting from orthodox Anglican belief.Profiles in Puritanism William Barker (dead link) His death was the occasion of an early Latin poem by John Milton.Thomas N. Corns, A Companion to Milton (2001), p. 111.Graham Parry, The Arts of the Anglican Counter-Reformation: Glory, Laud and Honour (2006), p. 154.
|
|
Little Sisters of the Poor Home for the Aged v. Burwell (2015), Gorsuch joined Judges Harris Hartz, Paul Joseph Kelly Jr., Timothy Tymkovich, and Jerome Holmes in their dissent to the denial of rehearing en banc.Little Sisters of the Poor Home for the Aged v. Burwell, 799 F.3d 1315 (10th Cir. 2015) (Hartz, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc).
|
|
While living in New Jersey in February 1840, Ivins was baptized into the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. In Spring 1841, Ivins moved to Nauvoo, Illinois to join the main gathering of church members On April 28, 1844, those dissenting from the leadership of Joseph Smith at Nauvoo formed their own church, appointing Ivins to the post of bishop.
|
|
R. Smith, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part) (9th Cir. Feb. 7, 2012) On February 21, 2012, Proponents petitioned the Ninth Circuit for rehearing en banc, which Plaintiffs opposed. The Ninth Circuit denied Proponents' petition on June 5, 2012. Judge Diarmuid O'Scannlain filed a short opinion dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc, which was joined by Judges Jay Bybee and Carlos Bea.
|
|
Chesham is noted for the religious dissent which dominated the town from the 15th century. In 1532 Thomas Harding was burnt at the stake in the town for being a Lollard and heretic. From the 17th century Chesham was a focus for those dissenting from mainstream religion. Quakers met in the late 17th century in Chesham and in 1798 they built the current meeting house.
|
|
Montbard in Vanity Fair, 1872 During the 1860s, dissenting from the British government's position, Newman Hall passionately supported the north in the American Civil War. He disapproved of secession by southern states. England should side with the North, he wrote, particularly because emancipation of the slaves is just. He felt so strongly that he published one of his few non-theological books: The American War.
|
|
Although he suggested Justice Kennedy's concurrence may be "more consequential" than Justice Harry Blackmun's dissent in Callins v. Collins,Callins v. Collins, (Blackmun, J., dissenting) ("From this day forward, I no longer shall tinker with the machinery of death."). Mark Joseph Stern described Justice Kennedy's concurrence as "myopic", noting that "large chunks of the 'legal academy' in the 'public' were aware—and outraged—by the practice long before Kennedy condemned it".
|
|
Twenty-two years after his death in 1667, the passing of the Toleration Act (1689) allowed dissenters to worship openly. For the free exercise of their Divine worship, Thomas Wilson of "Tunley within Wrightington " erected a chapel for Protestants dissenting from the Church of England. About a century later the congregation became Unitarian before the building was given to the Scottish Presbyterians. It now belongs to the Presbyterian Church of England.
|
|
Kiyemba v. Obama ("Kiyemba II"), 561 F.3d 509 (D.C. Cir. 2009): Dissenting from the panel's holding that a court cannot issue a writ of habeas corpus to prevent the transfer of a Guantanamo detainee to a country where the detainee claims he will be tortured or further detained, Griffith argued that the Suspension Clause entitles Guantanamo detainees to notice and an opportunity to challenge the lawfulness of proposed transfers.
|
|
However, he joined Lord Oliver of Aylmerton in dissenting from the majority decision in the Spycatcher case, criticising the government's case to prevent publication of the contents of Peter Wright's book as "ridiculous". He supported the majority decision in the Gillick case on medical consent in 1985, and in the McLoughlin v O'Brian case on recovery of damages for nervous shock. He was elected an honorary fellow of Wolfson College, Cambridge in 1989.
|
|
Amherst justified ending the tradition of giving goods and supplies to Indians in terms of defending His Majesty's interests. Indians would have to spend more time on supplying themselves, thus less time could be spent dissenting from British authority. By strictly limiting Native American's access to ammunition, Amherst was protecting the British Army from Indian attack. The decree denied Native groups access to alcohol and limited the amount of gunpowder they could legally obtain.
|
|
Consider the following argument: :(1) Sally accepts the assertion that "Cicero was a famous orator" while dissenting from the assertion that "Tully was a famous orator". :(2) Cicero is Tully :Therefore, (3) Sally believes that Tully was a famous orator. To derive (3), we have to assume that when Sally accepts that "Cicero was a famous orator", she believes that Cicero was a famous orator. Then we can exchange Cicero for Tully, and derive (3).
|
|
Justice William Brennan The Supreme Court reversed the judgment below, in an opinion authored by Justice William J. Brennan, joined by four other members of the Court.Justices John M. Harlan and Potter Stewart dissented. Justice Byron R. White, who had been Deputy Attorney General when the case was brought, recused himself. Justice Arthur Goldberg filed a separate memorandum not dissenting from the judgment but disagreeing with the Court's interpretation of the Clayton Act.
|
|
Carlton, "The Workingmen's Party of New York City," pg. 408. Those dissenting from the communal boarding school educational model were expelled. The Working Men's Party was thereby formally split. Evans editorialized upon the situation in the pages of his Working Man's Advocate, attributing the split to a "deliberate plot that has been lately unmasked" to subvert the Working Men's Party to the cause of electing National Republican orator Henry Clay as President of the United States.
|
|
A plurality opinion is in certain legal systems the opinion from one or more judges or justices of an appellate court which provides the rationale for the disposition of an appeal when no single opinion received the support of a majority of the court. The plurality opinion did not receive the support of more than half the justices, but still received more support than any other opinion, excluding those justices dissenting from the holding of the court.
|
|
Cotton was accepted to Harvard University after graduating from high school in 1995, and majored in government. At Harvard, Cotton was a member of the editorial board of The Harvard Crimson, often dissenting from the liberal majority. In articles, Cotton addressed what he saw as "sacred cows" such as affirmative action. He graduated with an A.B. magna cum laude in 1998 after only three years of study, having written his senior thesis on The Federalist Papers.
|
|
Douglas, joined by Black, furthered his advocacy of a broad reading of First Amendment rights by dissenting from the Supreme Court's decision in Dennis v. United States (1952), affirming the conviction of the leader of the U.S. Communist Party. In 1944, Douglas voted with the majority to uphold the wartime internment of Japanese Americans, in Korematsu v. United States but, over the course of his career, he grew to become a leading advocate of individual rights.
|
|
The arbitral tribunal issued its decision and award on 10 June 1992. It was a 3–2 decision, with the representatives of both Canada and France dissenting from the decision. The zone that was awarded to France was unusual and in two parts: first, the boundary was set at an equidistant line between the French islands and the Canadian island of Newfoundland. Added to this was a 24 nautical mile bulge on the west of the islands.
|
|
He was a member of the United Kingdom Sugar Industry Inquiry Committee from 1934–35, and submitted a minority report, dissenting from his colleagues' recommendation that public subsidy of sugar beet production should be discontinued."Mr Lloyd's minority report", The Manchester Guardian, 11 April 1935, p. 13 In 1959, when he was eighty-two, he received the Freedom of the County Borough of Dudley. Lloyd died at his home near Stourbridge at the age of eighty-six.
|
|
Judge Harris Hartz filed an opinion dissenting from denial of review en banc, in which he argued the Tenth Circuit's requirements for notices of removal were "even more onerous than the code pleading requirements that I had thought the federal courts abandoned long ago".Dart Cherokee, 730 F.3d at 1234. Judge Hartz concluded the Tenth Circuit had an "obligation" to grant review en banc "to provide clarity in this important area of the law".Dart Cherokee, 730 F.3d at 1238.
|
|
He owned O'Neill Motors, a Dublin garage acquired in 1959 by Ryan's Car Hire. O'Neill served on several committees and commissions on industry and commerce. During the First World War he chaired the All-Ireland Munitions and Government Supplies Committee, which tried with limited success to secure war-related contracts for Irish firms. He served on Lord Balfour of Burleigh's 1916–17 Committee on Commercial and Industrial Policy, dissenting from its final report in particular due to Ireland-specific issues.
|
|
Several months after the statement was issued, Dr. McEnroy joined 1,500 others in signing an open letter opposing the Pope's teachings on the subject. After reading the open letter in the National Catholic Reporter, the Archabbot determined that Dr. McEnroy must be removed from the faculty at Saint Meinrad for publicly dissenting from the Pope's teachings. Dr. McEnroy sued on a claim of breach of contract. The lower court dismissed the case, citing lack of jurisdiction, which decision was upheld on appeal.
|
|
Summum v. Pleasant Grove City, 499 F.3d 1170, 1175 (10th Cir. 2007) (McConnell, J., dissenting from denial of rehearing en banc).. Most of the dissent's view was subsequently adopted by the Supreme Court, which reversed the judgment of the Tenth Circuit. Gorsuch has written that "the law [...] doesn't just apply to protect popular religious beliefs: it does perhaps its most important work in protecting unpopular religious beliefs, vindicating this nation's long-held aspiration to serve as a refuge of religious tolerance".
|
|
The British Workers League was a 'patriotic labour' group which was anti- socialist and pro-British Empire. The League operated from 1916 to 1927. The league's origins lay in a split in the British Socialist Party in 1915, primarily over the need to win the First World War. A group, dissenting from the pacifism of the Labour Party, would be formed by Victor Fisher and supported "the eternal idea of nationality" and aimed to promote "socialist measures in the war effort".
|
|
Holyoake joined Charles Southwell in dissenting from the official policy of Owenism that lecturers should take a religious oath, to enable them to take collections on Sundays. Southwell had founded an atheist organization, Oracle of Reason, and was soon imprisoned on those grounds. Holyoake took over as editor, having moved to an atheist position as a result of his experiences. Holyoake was influenced by the French philosopher of science, Auguste Comte, notable in the discipline of sociology and famous for the doctrine of positivism.
|
|
In 1972, Blackmun joined Burger and the other two Nixon appointees to the Court in dissenting from the Furman v. Georgia decision that invalidated all capital punishment laws then in force in the United States, and in 1976, he voted to reinstate the death penalty in Gregg v. Georgia, even the mandatory death penalty statutes, although in both instances he indicated his personal opinion of its shortcomings as a policy. Blackmun, however, insisted his political opinions should have no bearing on the death penalty's constitutionality.
|
|
Some reasons for dissenting from the church's position on the legality of abortion, other than finding abortion morally acceptable, include "I am personally opposed to abortion, but I think the Church is concentrating its energies too much on abortion rather than on social action"Mary T. Hanna, Catholics and American Politics (Harvard University Press 1979 ), p. 154 or "I do not wish to impose my views on others."John Finnis, Religion and Public Reasons(Oxford University Press 2011 ), vol. 5, p. 122Susan Elizabeth Davis, Women under Attack (South End Press 1999 ), p.
|
|
Additionally, Ratramnus wrote an odd Letter on the Dog-headed Creatures,Ratramnus, Epist. de cynocephalis ad Rimbertum presbyterum scripta, PL 121:1153-6; Dutton, "Ratramnus and the Dog-headed Humans" dissenting from the commonly held belief that the mythical cynocephali were animals. Instead, he argued, those creatures who domesticate animals must be rational and therefore related to human beings, not animals.McCracken, Early Medieval Theology, 110; Steel, How to Make a Human, 145-50 Ratramnus wrote another treatise, The Birth of Christ,PL 121:81-102 possibly as a response to Paschasius’ De Partu Virginis.
|
|
In 1881, he was elected circuit judge, and was elevated to the state supreme court in 1885. As a justice, his opinions were described as "concise, expressed in terse and vigorous phrases, and manifest a decided inclination to follow adjudged cases". In one case, the court considered one of Black's own previous opinions from his tenure as a circuit judge. When it came before the Supreme Court, all the judges voted to affirm except Black, who filed a brief opinion dissenting from the opinion affirming his previous decision.
|
|
The True Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints or True Mormon Church was a denomination of the Latter Day Saint movement. It was founded in the spring of 1844 in Nauvoo, Illinois, by leaders dissenting from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. The Reformed Church's president was William Law, a former counselor to the movement's founder, Joseph Smith (then President of the Church). Law was joined by his brother, Wilson Law, along with Robert D. Foster, Charles A. Foster, Francis M. Higbee, Chauncey L. Higbee and Charles Ivins.
|
|
These facts should have nullified the decision of the committee and the Assembly on the grounds that it had left some members as judges of their own cases, Bradley argued. Finally, Bradley cited irregularities in the proceedings of the contest committee, including giving insufficient time for the review of testimony provided in written form by Taylor and Marshall's legal representation. The court refused to intervene in the case, however, because it found that there were no federal questions involved. The lone justice dissenting from that opinion was Kentuckian John Marshall Harlan.
|
|
By 1977, Kambona had turned against Nyerere, accusing the latter of being a dictator. Over the following years, various MPs were expelled for corruption and other crimes—they claimed, however, that they were being expelled for dissenting from Nyerere's positions. US President Jimmy Carter, Nyerere, and US First Lady Rosalynn Carter, in the white house 1977 By the mid-1970s, there was much speculation that Nyerere would resign. TANU again nominated him for the presidency in 1975, but in his speech he warned against repeatedly electing the same person.
|
|
When he retired, Boyd said he would like most to be remembered for his dissents to opinions that later were overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court. One of those cases was when he disagreed with the majority of the justices who had ordered The Miami Herald to give equal access on its editorial pages to a political candidate. The federal justices, though, agreed with Boyd and ruled that would violate the First Amendment's freedom of the press protections. He also once used Biblical logic in dissenting from a ruling that upheld Florida's vagrancy law.
|
|
It was not meant to be viewed as adults telling children how to live, rather it was children telling their peers how good life in Russia was. The point of this was to create a sense of unity with one another in order to keep the Soviet ideals in line and not have those who diverged and spoke against the strict guidelines. Despite the effort demonstrated by the government, their work was not as fruitful as they had hoped. The book shows the main characters dissenting from this through their production of samizdat which leads to the discussion on censorship.
|
|
The CFTC's dissatisfaction with the Broker-Dealer Lite proposal and the fact it was issued without a PWG meeting is expressed by Chairwoman Born at pages 11-14 of the June 10, 1998, Hearing before House Subcommittee on Risk Management and Specialty Crops. In the ensuing Congressional hearings, the three members of the PWG dissenting from the CFTC's "unilateral" actions argued the CFTC was not the proper body, and the CEA was not the proper statute, to regulate OTC derivatives activities. Banks and securities firms dominated the OTC derivatives market. Their regulators needed to be involved in any regulation of the market.
|
|
Amash at the 2012 Liberty Political Action Conference Amash has described himself as a libertarian, dissenting from both Republican and Democratic leaderships more frequently than the vast majority of Republican members of Congress. Amash is regarded as one of the most libertarian members of Congress, receiving high scores from right-leaning interest groups such as the Club for Growth, Heritage Action for America, and Americans for Prosperity, and praise from limited-government think tanks and nonprofit organizations. He was a founding member of the House Freedom Caucus, a group of conservative Republicans in the House. In June 2019, Amash left the caucus.
|
|
In front of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in 1994, Brown sought to overturn his convictions based on his contention that the synagogue was owned by a corporation and not by citizens, and thus could not be covered by 42 U.S.C. Sec. 1982 (1988) which he argued applied solely to the property rights of citizens. Brown challenged as unwarranted the seizure of his personal property. The three-judge court upheld the convictions on March 21, 1995, with Circuit Judge Alice M. Batchelder dissenting from the main opinion of Boyce F. Martin, Jr. and Richard Alan Enslen.
|
|
Justice Whittaker, joined by Justice Black and Justice Douglas, wrote an opinion concurring in the dismissal of the indictment against James, but dissenting from the overruling of Wilcox. Justice Black raised a Federalism argument, arguing that this ruling constituted a preemption of state criminal jurisdiction. Justice Harlan, joined by Justice Frankfurter, wrote an opinion concurring with the overruling of Wilcox, but contending that James should have been set for a new trial, rather than set free of criminal liability. Justice Clark wrote a brief concurrence, also agreeing with the overruling of Wilcox, but stating that James' conviction should also have been upheld.
|
|
He was a lieutenant colonel at the battles of Lexington and Concord in April 1775. Thereafter, until the end of 1776, he served as colonel in command of several regiments of the Massachusetts Line.Francis B. Heitman, Historical Register of Officers of the Continental Army during the War of the Revolution, new, enlarged, and revised edition (Washington, D.C.: Rare Book Shop Publishing Company, 1914), p. 460. In war counsels during the 1776 defense of New York City, Read urged the evacuation of the American fortifications, dissenting from generals such as Nathanael Greene who urged that the forts be defended.
|
|
The term cafeteria Catholic is applied to those who assert a Catholic faith yet dissent from one or more doctrinal or moral teachings of the Catholic church or who are viewed as dissenting by those using the term. Examples include Catholics who are accused of dissenting from any or all of the Church teachings on human sexuality and things related (the so-called "pelvic issues", i.e., what it has to say about abortion, birth control, divorce, premarital sex, masturbation, pornography, prostitution and the moral status of homosexual acts) or, alternately, those who demonstrate no concern for any moral issues except abortion and contraception.
|
|
He was appointed minister of Pencaitland, in the county of East Lothian, in about 1640, where he was one of those appointed to draw up The Directory for Public Worship in Scotland. He continued to take an active part in the affairs of the church, and introduced in 1649 the practice, now confirmed by long usage, of dissenting from the decision of the General Assembly, and requiring the protest to be entered in the record. His last years were devoted to the preparation of The Historie of the Kirk of Scotland which was published in an abridged form in 1646.
|
|
Although the Chinese had their own reasons to enter the war, mentioned above, the view that the Soviets had used them as proxies was shared by the Western bloc. MacArthur was a notable exception, dissenting from this prevailing view in his "Old Soldiers Never Die" speech. China had to use a Soviet loan, which had been originally intended to rebuild their destroyed economy, to pay for Soviet arms. From official Chinese sources, PVA Korean War casualty figures break down as follows: 114,084 killed in action; 380,000 total wounded in action; 70,000 died of wounds or sickness; and 25,621 missing.
|
|
Elie Kedourie (25 January 1926 – 29 June 1992, Washington) was a British historian of the Middle East. He wrote from a liberal perspective, dissenting from many points of view taken as orthodox in the field. He was employed at the London School of Economics (LSE) from 1953 to 1990, becoming Professor of Politics. Kedourie was famous for his rejection of what he called the "Chatham House version" of history, which viewed the story of the modern Middle East as one of continuous victimisation at the hands of the West, and instead castigated left-wing Western intellectuals for what he regarded as a naively romantic view of Islam.
|
|
Both nations use extensive firewall systems to block any information from the Internet which they perceive to be offensive or threatening to their regimes. If a citizen of these nations is caught dissenting from the nation using the Internet then they may face severe penalties, even the removal of civil liberties. In contrast to this, censorship which has been initiated by the United States is focused more on the protection of intellectual property. While the right to proportion of one's individual ideas is recognized, there is widespread fear that wide-ranging powers awarded in anti-piracy laws will lead to the abuse of freedom of expression and censorship.
|
|
Courtesy copy here. The "Order Denying Rehearing En Banc" includes the Summary Order of February 15, 2008 as Appendix A, and also includes the district court decision of September 28, 2006 as Appendix B. Judge José Cabranes and Chief Judge Dennis Jacobs wrote opinions in dissent from the denial of rehearing, urging review by the Supreme Court.Judge Cabranes wrote the principal dissent from the Second Circuit's denial of rehearing en banc, and his dissent is available in the "Order Denying Rehearing En Banc". Jacobs Opinion, dissenting from the Second Circuit's denial of rehearing en banc; this dissent accompanies some published versions of the "Order Denying Rehearing En Banc".
|
|
It provided Hugh Stowell, rector of St Stephen's Church in Salford, with a platform to "wage war" on any group dissenting from the orthodox views of the Anglican Church, notably Catholics and Jews, but also including Unitarians, whom Stowell doubted even had the right to call themselves Christians. The daily Manchester Evening Mail, established by Thomas Sowler junior in 1874 and closed in 1902, was a companion publication and one of several newspapers which began around that time with the intention of providing a less highbrow alternative to their longer-established stablemates. The introduction of the Mail coincided with the Courier becoming a weekly newspaper.
|
|
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg filed an opinion dissenting in part and dissenting from the judgment. She agreed with the majority's interpretation of the FDPCA statute of limitations, but asserted that the fraudulent actions alleged in the complaint should warrant the application of the discovery rule, starting the statute of limitations on the date that he learned of the default judgment (in 2014). She considers this fraud-based discovery rule distinct from the generic discovery rule rejected by the majority, and would apply it even in cases where the generic discovery rule does not apply. Ginsburg's opinion also challenges the claim that Rotkiske failed to preserve the fraud argument in his appeals.
|
|
The New York Times published two reader letters, dissenting from Chu's essay "My New Vagina Won't Make Me Happy." The letters were published under the title "Feeling Better After Gender Transition." Kai Cheng Thom, writing in Slate, offered a detailed criticism of "My New Vagina Won't Make Me Happy." Conceding that Chu is "often brilliant," Thom criticized Chu's New York Times essay as potentially damaging to the cause of trans acceptance, by confirming "unfortunate stereotypes of how people talk and write about trans people." Thom went on to say: > [I]n her piece, she uses sensational language that feeds the lurid interest > in trans people’s bodies at the expense of our rights and privacy.
|
|
Kitty Packe Kitty Packe, who was wife of the lord of the manor, was much concerned in the middle of the nineteenth century as to the strength of those dissenting from the established Anglican church, saying "Now I can sympathise with anybody in Dislike to Dissent but I have no dislike of the poor dissenters. I would not willingly let a cottage or a farm to a dissenter, and even for an allotment I would give a preference to a Church (i.e. Anglican) person". Compared to another local village who have a number of agnostics and Independents, she says "I have much reason to be thankful in Great Glen that we only have Wesleyans as dissenters among the poor".
|
|
The National Indian Youth Council (NIYC) was established in 1961 by young American Indians who were either in college or had recently graduated. The NIYC is a result of youths dissenting from tribal leaders, which began during the American Indian Chicago Conference in 1961, where several young American Indians, a handful of who had become acquainted while participating in the Southwest Regional Indian Youth Council, became disillusioned with the tribal leaders.[1]:53-54. After listening to the ideas presented by the conservative faction of the conference, the youth began to express dissenting opinions. This group, including Clyde Warrior (Ponca) and Mel Thom (Walker River Paiute), temporarily called themselves the Chicago Conference Youth Council.[1]:57.
|
|
Montgomery v. United States, 414 U.S. 935 (1973) (Douglas, J., dissenting from the denial of certiorari). The Court has since elaborated on the basis for its holding in Cramer: > This holding was based upon the well-understood governmental policy of > encouraging the Indian to forgo his wandering habits and adopt those of > civilized life; and it was said that to hold that by so doing he acquired no > possessory rights to the lands occupied, to which the government would > accord protection, would be contrary to the whole spirit of the traditional > American policy toward these dependent wards of the nation. The fact that > such right of occupancy finds no recognition in any statute or other formal > governmental action is not conclusive.Cent. Pac.
|
|
Justice John Paul Stevens filed an opinion that was joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, concurring that the search violated the Fourth Amendment, but dissenting from the view that the school officials were entitled to qualified immunity. Stevens would have denied qualified immunity to assistant principal Wilson, writing that "this is, in essence, a case in which clearly established law meets clearly outrageous conduct".Redding, 557 U.S. 364, 380 (Stevens, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part). He disagreed that the "seemingly divergent views" among lower courts of appeals about T. L. O.’s application to strip searches justifies extending qualified immunity, stating that "the clarity of a well-established right should not depend on whether jurists have misread our precedents".
|
|
According to progressive scholar Mark Rupert, the right-wing anti-globalist worldview of business nationalists “envisions a world in which Americans are uniquely privileged, inheritors of a divinely inspired socio–political order which must at all costs be defended against external intrusions and internal subversion.” Rupert argues that this reactionary analysis seeks to challenge corporate power without comprehending the nature of “capital concentration and the transnational socialization of production.” The reactionary analysis absent this understanding breeds social alienation and intensifies “scapegoating and hostility toward those seen as outside of, different or dissenting from its vision of national identity." As alienation builds, more overtly fascistic forces will attempt to pull some of these angry people into an ideological framework that further justifies demonization of the chosen "Other.
|
|
The Willoughbys of Parham, of Shaw Place, Heath Charnock were prominent Presbyterians. and Hugh Willoughby was one of the first trustees and benefactors of the chapel, which was built in 1703 on land named Goosehey given for a peppercorn rent on a 2000-year lease by John Andrews of Rivington Manor, with the stipulation it should only be used for religious services of Protestants dissenting from the Church of England. The chapel was built of four bays measuring 40 by 30 yards. By 1704 a formal trust deed had been signed and by 1737 the chapel was well funded. Rev. John Turner, minister here 1716 to 1717 had assisted the defeat of the Jacobite rising at the Battle of Preston 1715.
|
|
In the opinion of Pattison, "as a refutation of Scioppius it is most complete"; but there are certainly grounds for dissenting from this judgment. Scaliger purported that Scioppius committed more blunders than he corrected, claiming that the book made untruthful allegations; but he did not succeed in adducing any proof either of his father's descent from the La Scala family, or of any of the events narrated by Julius prior to his arrival at Agen. Nor does Scaliger attempt a refutation of the crucial point, namely, that William, the last prince of Verona, had no son Nicholas, who would have been the alleged grandfather of Julius. But whether complete or not, the Confutatio had little success; the attack attributed to the Jesuits was successful.
|
|
During her tenure on the court, she was regarded as perhaps its most controversial member, and as someone who usually only slept four hours a day so she could focus on her work. Critics labelled her a feminist, equal-rights ideologue because of her support for the battered woman defense, tax deductions for mothers in the workforce, expansive provisions for spousal support, and the protection of sexual-assault complainants' privacy. During her time on the court, she was a proponent of equality rights of women, immigrants, LGBT people, and other minority groups. L'Heureux-Dubé heard more than 1200 Supreme Court cases, wrote 254 judgments, dissenting from the majority in about 40 percent of them, which earned her the label of the "great dissenter".
|
|
Judge Diana Gribbon Motz wrote the plurality opinion, which held that, as a legal resident of the United States who was originally detained in the United States, al-Marri could not be held in military custody as an enemy combatant. The court also held that the Military Commissions Act does not strip federal courts of jurisdiction to hear habeas corpus petitions from alleged enemy combatants arrested and detained within the borders of the United States. The court ordered the government to either charge al-Marri with a crime, initiate deportation proceedings, or release him. Dissenting from the opinion, Judge Henry E. Hudson indicated that he believed Bush possessed the authority to detain alleged sleeper agents such as al-Marri, "the type of stealth warrior used by Al Qaeda".
|
|
In later years these miniature scenes came to be more highly regarded than the figures they accompany." Dissenting from the general tone of praise for Bewick, Jacob Kainen cites claims that "many of the best tailpieces in the History of British birds were drawn by Robert Johnson", and that "the greater number of those contained in the second volume were engraved by Clennell. Granted that the outlook and the engraving style were Bewick's, and that these were notable contributions, the fact that the results were so close to his own points more to an effective method of illustration than to the outpourings of genius." Kainen argues that while competent, Bewick "was no Holbein, no Botticelli—it is absurd to think of him in such terms—but he did develop a fresh method of handling wood engraving.
|
|
Goldberg argued in a 1963 internal Supreme Court memorandum that imposition of the death penalty was condemned by the international community and should be regarded as "cruel and unusual punishment," in contravention of the Eighth Amendment. Finding support in this position from two other justices (William J. Brennan and William O. Douglas), Goldberg published an opinion dissenting from the Court's denial of certiorari in a case, Rudolph v. Alabama, involving the imposition of the death penalty for rape, in which Goldberg cited the fact that only five nations responding to a UN survey indicated that they allowed imposition of the death penalty for rape, including the U.S., and that 33 states in the U.S. had outlawed the practice. Goldberg's dissent sent a signal to lawyers across the nation to challenge the constitutionality of capital punishment in appeals.
|
|
In 2004, a paper was published in the journal Science by Naomi Oreskes titled Beyond the Ivory Tower: The Scientific Consensus on Climate Change. It researched the hypothesis that legitimate dissenting opinions on anthropogenic climate change might be downplayed in scientific papers and concluded that 75% of the examined abstracts either explicitly or implicitly backed the consensus view, none directly dissenting from it. The essay received a great deal of media attention from around the world and has been cited by many prominent people including as Al Gore in the movie An Inconvenient Truth, the Royal Society and former Chief Scientific Advisor to the UK Government, Prof Sir David King. Peiser identified an error in this paper in that keywords used in the ISI database search were in fact "global climate change" and not "climate change" as originally stated, which resulted in a correction being published by Science.
|
|
" Melanie McDonagh, writing in The Telegraph, states that with A Book of Mediterranean Food, David "introduced the Brits to the cooking of Greece, Italy and Provence in 1950 after her return from Greece, via Egypt and India". She comments that the cookery writer Jane Grigson, a "devotee", said "Basil was no more than the name of bachelor uncles, courgette was printed in italics as an alien word, and few of us knew how to eat spaghetti ... Then came Elizabeth David, like sunshine." McDonagh adds that David "was one of the first and much the classiest of the personality food writers, even though she was never a telly chef: paving the way for Jamie, Nigella, Nigel and Hugh F-W." Dissenting from the general acclaim, Tom Norrington-Davies, also writing in The Telegraph, argues that the book "reached only a very small section of the population", but at once qualifies this, stating that these readers were "undergoing a dramatic upheaval.
|
|
Vicki Cole and sign in the Inaugural Parade Deshler, Ohio fire department, where the "Nixonettes" assembled The Inaugural Committee wanted to adopt "Bring Us Together" as the inaugural theme, appalling Safire, who said, "That wasn't the theme of the campaign." Safire and other aides felt the administration should seek to advance its agenda, rather than seeking consensus on policy, and White House Chief of Staff-designate H. R. Haldeman was able to change the theme to "Forward Together." Nevertheless, the phrase "Bring Us Together" was thrown in the face of the Nixon administration by Democrats each time something divisive was proposed, and was used as the title of a tell-all expose by Leon Panetta after he was fired from the Nixon administration for dissenting from the White House's "Southern strategy" on civil rights policy. According to Safire, the use of the phrase against Nixon shows a slogan which evokes emotion can cut both ways.
|
|
The signatories stated: "We regard Diana Johnstone's Fools' Crusade as an outstanding work, dissenting from the mainstream view but doing so by an appeal to fact and reason, in a great tradition.""To whom it may concern" , hagglundsforlag (Sweden)"Attack of the Zarembites", Ordfront (Sweden), April 2004 Ed Vulliamy, who reported for The Guardian during the Bosnian War, called Johnstone's book "poison" finding unbelievable the response of Chomsky and the others.Ed Vuillamy "Comment: We Must Fight for Memory of Bosnia's Camps", BCR [Balkan Crisis Report], Issue 513, 21 February 2005, Institute For War & Peace Reporting website In March 2006, David Aaronovitch in The Times wrote: "In the sense that the world understood there to have been an act amounting to genocide at Srebrenica ... Johnstone certainly, and Chomsky implicitly, had most certainly denied the massacre". In the book "and elsewhere she had argued that the numbers of deaths had been exaggerated, that many supposed victims were in fact still alive somewhere, that Srebrenica had actually been an armed camp, that the Bosnians had deliberately let it be overrun hoping for a anti- Serb propaganda coup, that there had been some regrettable 'revenge' killings, as can happen in wartime".
|
|